Parenthood: "She’s So White!"

While I was party planning this afternoon, I started watching last night’s episode of ‘Parenthood’. Barely five minutes in, I fell over laughing when Crosby held up his newly-born daughter and exclaimed with shock, “She’s so white!” And 10 minutes in, I nearly died again when Grandpa Braverman said, “She’s even lighter than she was in the hospital!” and then expressed his confusion at the term light-skinned. Ah… All of this is so familiar to parents of biracial children.

Pop Culture Dad and I had the same reaction when Little Diva was born. I mean, we knew she would likely be born much more pale than she would eventually end up. Many black children (particularly with lighter-skinned parents) and most biracial kids are. My doula with Little Diva has biracial grandchildren, and she tried to prep us for the possibility before we went into the delivery room. This wasn’t an earth shattering revelation. I was a pale child, and I’ve been around plenty of black and biracial newborns. I don’t know any black person who would be particularly shocked by the revelation that some black and biracial babies will be darn-near white at birth.
What Pop Culture Dad and I were not prepared for, however, was that our then-blue eyed (now green), pale child, would pretty much stay pale—very pale—for years. My multi-ethnic mother comes from a long line of “high yella” women. My dad’s mother was also very beige. But I’m brown. And my mother-in-law is a pretty deep tan. My husband isn’t even that pale himself. Somehow, though, for the first three-and-a-half years of her life, our baby girl was lighter than her father.
This was a real problem for me when Little Diva was a baby. Despite the fact that she looks just like my toddler pictures, when it was just the two of us, people often asked me if she was my child or just assumed I was the nanny. I was so glad when she learned to talk and started calling me “Mommy” in public, so the people who were staring and trying to figure things out would look away. I also bought her several shirts that said things like “She’s my mommy, not the nanny!” or which hadn’t picture of a vanilla/chocolate ice cream cone baring the slogan “Swirled!” Even now that Little Diva has (finally) got a little bit of a tan, her skin color is often a topic of conversation among people. Annoying…
All of this “nanny” and “OMG, she looks white” [she does not] stuff is perhaps why immediately after giving birth to Super Girl, I exclaimed, “Oh, thank goodness! She has some color!” No one wants to be called the nanny.
I’ll be interested to see as the season plays out, if Jasmine will experience any of the “Uh… Is that… um… your baby,… or, uh… are you the, um….?” nonsense that so many black mothers of biracial (or just light-skinned) babies deal with. If there are any black writers (or white writers with biracial families) on staff, I imagine it’s coming.


4 thoughts on “Parenthood: "She’s So White!"

  1. i know this is an old post, but i found your site while googling white biracial babies. im a black woman who just gave birth to a beautiful healthy white baby lol. his father is white and i get the confused looks all the time. Its like when you see a white woman holding a brown baby you go “oh she must of had a baby with a darker man” but a black chick holding a white baby??? doesn’t compute with people. i secretly hope he gets some color as time goes on and i def saw that episode of parenthood and had a good laugh myself. and this was before i was pregnant! anyways, thanks for the article and knowing im not alone 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • I had a friend say to me the other day about an old picture of my oldest daughter, “You know, I can always pick out one of my own, but sorry, she’s not black. Poor nanny.” She was joking, but that’s seriously how the first year or two felt. Luckily, she’s grown to where you can tell she’s biracial or at least Creole [we’re in Texas; not uncommon]. Also, now at age 7, she is vocally, unapologetically black, so even if someone were to still mistake her for anything but half black, she would correct them in a heartbeat.

      You’re definitely not alone! Good luck!


  2. Hi! Regarding specifically about the pop culture part – Tv show Parenthood, Aida was a white baby for the whole 5th season (like reallly white, not a “lighter skin” that could eventually get less white), and then season 6 starts and….voilà, we have a black baby 🤣🤣.

    No problem with any baby color. But a big problem with lack of logic and continuation details.


    • Oh I completely agree with taking issue with continuity errors! We were watching a movie this weekend, and five minutes into it, one of the character’s shoes changed colors. My husband rewound it several times to confirm, and then the movie was just ruined for us. Spent the rest of it looking for a more sloppy editing errors. 😂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s